Post by Pocket Ponyo on Apr 26, 2008 17:11:26 GMT -5
Edna is my favorite character on the show, and several stellar episodes surrounding her have been produced. The purpose of this thread is to see what everyone thinks the best Edna episode is.
For me, it has to be Grade School Confidential, followed closely by Bart the Lover.
My grades:
Bart the Lover: A+
Grade School Confidential: A+
Special Edna: A-
My Big Fat Geek Wedding: D+
The Seemingly Never-Ending Story: B-
Nothing much to say about my reasons for the grades, except that it's very hard for me to get any enjoyment out of "Wedding" as it ruined my favorite relationship in the show, and is a prime example of how Jean always tries to return everything to the status quo.
And I know that The Seemingly Never-Ending Story isn't exactly an Edna episode, but since she played a big enough part, I decided to include it anyway. There also is an "other" option just in case I forgot any episodes.
EDIT: It won't let me add a poll... if a mod could do that for me, that would be great.
For me, it has to be Grade School Confidential, followed closely by Bart the Lover.
My grades:
Bart the Lover: A+
Grade School Confidential: A+
Special Edna: A-
My Big Fat Geek Wedding: D+
The Seemingly Never-Ending Story: B-
Nothing much to say about my reasons for the grades, except that it's very hard for me to get any enjoyment out of "Wedding" as it ruined my favorite relationship in the show, and is a prime example of how Jean always tries to return everything to the status quo.
And I know that The Seemingly Never-Ending Story isn't exactly an Edna episode, but since she played a big enough part, I decided to include it anyway. There also is an "other" option just in case I forgot any episodes.
EDIT: It won't let me add a poll... if a mod could do that for me, that would be great.
