Most Overrated Episodes

[starman]

These are easily the most overrated episodes of all time:

Rosebud
Last Exit to Springfield
Homer at the Bat

These are just overrated:

Marge vs. the Monorail
HOMR (not only overrated, but a pile of %&$# if you ask me)
Lisa's Substitute (It's probably the most overrated, but the thing is, I can see why this time)

---

Rosebud, is a 'good' episode at best. I wouldn't ever separate it from the rest of Season 5, but compared to the other brilliant episodes, it's nothing special.

Last Exit To Springfield, is a better episode, but even more overrated. Again, still a great episode, but I would never separate this episode from the rest of the season. Never.

Homer at the Bat, is my least favourite episode from the first 3 seasons, and Season 5 & 7 as well. I really, really hate it. What makes that even worse, is that so much people actually consider it the best of Season 3, which literally makes me laugh.

[Jye]

Rosebud
Last Exit To Springfield
Lisa's Substitute
Colonel Homer
The Last Temptation Of Homer
Fear Of Flying

[starman]

I'd say Fear of Flying was vastly underrated. I guess that's just me though.

[Inamon]

22 Short Films About Springfield (I'd pefer Trilogy of Error)
Marge vs. The Monorail
Dead Putting Soceity
Bart The General
HOMR
[glow=red,2,300][shadow=red,left,300]Lisa's Sax[/shadow][/glow]
Last Exit To Springfield

[Mike]

Rosebud
22 Short Films About Springfield
Lisa's Substitute
Mr. Plow
Duffless
A Streetcar Named Marge

They're all really good, just overrated.

[starman]

I love 'Lisa's Sax' simply because of that amazing clip montage at the end.

[Inamon]

That episode is defined overrated-tion (Word?). Bart worried of school because Willie threatened him and didn't get good grades.

Wow. I can't seriously tell you how much that could have been improved.

Oh, and I find The Way We Was and Bart's Inner Child overrated.

[starman]

'Bart's Inner Child' is still great, but yes, it is quite overrated. Personally, I don't find 'The Way We Was' overrated at all, because it's the best Homer-Marge episode I've ever seen.

[Inamon]

Disregard on The Way We Was; I meant In Marge We Trust

[starman]

Hwah? Even though it's not fantastic, that one's pretty much universally underrated, even the guys on the commentary think it. Oh well.

[Mike]

I forgot to mention Lisa's pony as being overrated.

[Jye]

Oh yeah, I think that one is way overrated.

[starman]

I thought that episode was the first sign of true brilliance in the show. That episode was just so great joke-wise, animation-wise, and it had an overall...feel to it that I find unbeatable.

[Jye]

It was good, but I think there are many episodes out there that beat it, and don't get recognised as much.

[harleenquinn]

Krusty Gets Busted
Three Men and a Comic Book
Flaming Moe's
Colonel Homer
A Streetcar Named Marge
Homer the Heretic
Mr. Plow
Lisa's First Word
I Love Lisa
Duffless
Krusty Gets Kancelled
Rosebud
Lisa On Ice
Homer: Badman
Bart's Comet
Homie The Clown
Lemon of Troy
Bart Sells His Soul
Mother Simpson
22 Short Films About Springfield
Summer of 4ft 2
You Only Move Twice
Lisa's Date With Density

And probably the most overrated episode of all time: Homer's Enemy